Group Lessons vs. Private Lessons: Which is better?
Welcome to the Raising Musos podcast/blog, where we share music education tips to help parents support their child’s musical journey. My name is Eliza Bourgault, and today, we’re diving into an important question: Are group lessons or private lessons better for your child?
Both options have unique advantages and disadvantages, and the best choice depends on your child’s personality, learning style, and musical goals. Let’s explore the pros and cons of each!
Group Lessons
Advantages
Social Benefits & Motivation
Peer Support: Students learn together and from each other, making practice more enjoyable.
Accountability: Seeing peers progress can inspire students to stay committed and practice regularly.
Teamwork & Leadership: Playing in an ensemble teaches cooperation, listening, and timing.
Interactive Learning: Games, ensemble work, and collaboration make lessons more engaging.
Long-Lasting Connections: Making music together fosters friendships and shared experiences.
Musical Growth
Ear Training: Playing with others enhances rhythmic and harmonic awareness.
Improved Listening Skills: Group settings encourage careful listening to instructors and peers, strengthening musical perception.
Performance Confidence: Regular group playing reduces stage fright and builds self-assurance.
Exposure to Different Perspectives: Students see multiple approaches to learning and problem-solving.
Holistic Development: Playing in a group improves teamwork, attention to detail, pulse control, and the ability to follow and lead.
Cost-Effective & Appropriate for Beginners
Lower Cost: Group lessons are generally more affordable than private instruction.
Gentler Introduction: Many young children aren’t ready for the intensity of one-on-one lessons. Group learning provides a fun, low-pressure environment.
Disadvantages
Less Individual Attention: Teachers must divide their time among multiple students.
More Temptation to Lose Focus: Some students may find it harder to concentrate in a group setting.
Private Lessons
Advantages
Personalized Learning
One-on-One Attention: Lessons are tailored to the student’s individual needs, pace, and learning style.
Focused Skill Development: Students can spend extra time on technical challenges like finger placement, breath control, and rhythm.
Fewer Distractions: A private setting allows for deeper concentration and more productive lessons.
In-Depth Exploration: Students can explore specific genres, composition, improvisation, and music theory in greater detail.
Confidence Building: A private setting provides a safe space to ask questions, make mistakes, and receive feedback without peer judgment.
Disadvantages
Fewer Opportunities to Apply Lessons: Without group practice, students may have fewer chances to apply what they learn in a collaborative setting.
Less Motivation to Practice: Students must rely on self-discipline rather than peer accountability.
Lack of Social Interaction: Private lessons don’t provide the same community experience as group settings.
Higher Cost: Private instruction is typically more expensive.
Which One Should You Choose?
The best choice depends on your child’s age, personality, and level of commitment:
For very young children, group lessons may be the best option. They provide a fun, interactive introduction to music without the pressure of individual performance.
For students who are unsure about their musical interest, group lessons allow them to explore music in a social and engaging environment before committing to private instruction.
For passionate and dedicated students, private lessons offer a tailored approach that accelerates progress and allows for a deeper focus on technique and musicality.
Consider your budget. If cost is a factor, group lessons provide an affordable way to get started, while private lessons require a higher investment.
Ultimately, both group and private lessons have incredible benefits. The key is finding what works best for your child’s learning style, interests, and goals.
At Music Makers Academy, we offer both group and private lessons in harp, piano, guitar, violin, and flute/piccolo. If you're unsure which option is best for your child, we'd love to help! Contact us today to learn more and book a free consultation.
📧 Email: hello@musicmakersacademy.com.au
📍 Location: 33/27 Piccadilly Circle, Joondalup WA 6027
📞 Phone: 0466 515 194
🎶 Let’s make music together! 🎶
